MINI Roadster (R59): The Comprehensive Buyer's Guide
The MINI Roadster (R59) is a two-seater convertible variant of the iconic MINI Cooper, produced from 2012 to 2015. It belongs to the subcompact roadster class, offering open-top thrills in a stylish and relatively affordable package. It's essentially a convertible version of the MINI Coupe (R58), but with a softer character leaning towards wind-in-your-hair motoring rather than outright performance.
A Brief History
Building upon the success of the MINI Hatch and Convertible, BMW sought to expand the MINI lineup with more niche models. The Roadster aimed to capture the market of enthusiasts who desired a small, sporty, and stylish open-top experience, similar to the Mazda MX-5 Miata, but with the distinct MINI flair. While sharing many components with other MINI models, the Roadster features a unique design with a steeply raked windshield and a distinctive rear spoiler, giving it a sporty profile, especially when the soft top is down.
Generations
The MINI Roadster (R59) falls under a single generation, produced from 2012 to 2015.
- 2012-2015 (R59): This encompasses the entire production run of the MINI Roadster. There were no significant generational changes during this period, but there were model year updates that primarily focused on equipment and styling.
- Key Features: Two-seater configuration, electrically operated soft top (standard on most models), automatic raising rollover bars, unique Roadster styling, shared mechanicals with other MINI models.
Reliability & Common Issues
The MINI Roadster, being closely related to other MINI models, shares many of their strengths and weaknesses. Reliability can be variable, and preventative maintenance is crucial. Here's a breakdown of common issues:
Engine Issues
- Timing Chain Issues (N14/N18 Engines): The pre-LCI (Life Cycle Impulse) models with the N14 engine (Cooper S) are notorious for timing chain problems. Symptoms include rattling on startup, rough running, and eventually, engine damage. The updated N18 engine (Cooper S from late 2012 onwards) is significantly more reliable, but still benefits from shorter oil change intervals (5,000-7,500 miles). Listen carefully for any chain noise during startup.
- High-Pressure Fuel Pump (HPFP) Failure (N14/N18 Engines): The HPFP on the Cooper S models is another known weak point, especially on the N14. Symptoms include long cranking times, misfires, and a loss of power.
- Oil Leaks: Valve cover gaskets, oil filter housing gaskets, and crankshaft seals are common sources of oil leaks on all MINI engines. Regular inspection is vital.
- Coolant Leaks: Thermostat housings and water pumps are prone to leaks, leading to overheating if not addressed promptly.
- Carbon Buildup (Direct Injection Engines): Direct injection engines like the N14 and N18 are susceptible to carbon buildup on the intake valves, which can reduce performance and fuel economy. Walnut blasting or other cleaning methods may be necessary.
Transmission Issues
- Automatic Transmission Problems: The Aisin automatic transmission, while generally reliable, can experience issues with valve body failure, leading to harsh shifting or slippage. Regular fluid changes (every 60,000 miles) are recommended.
- Manual Transmission Clutch Wear: Clutch wear is dependent on driving style, but aggressive use can shorten its lifespan considerably. Check for slippage during acceleration.
Electrical Issues
- Soft Top Mechanism Problems: While usually reliable, the electric soft top can experience issues with the motors or sensors. Ensure the top operates smoothly and completely. Check for any error messages on the dashboard.
- Sensor Failures: MINIs are known for being sensitive to sensor failures, which can trigger various warning lights. A diagnostic scan can pinpoint the culprit.
- Battery Drain: A parasitic drain on the battery can occur, especially in older models. Proper diagnostics are required to identify the source.
Other Issues
- Suspension Components: The suspension components, such as bushings and ball joints, can wear out over time, leading to a noisy or loose ride.
- Rust: While generally well-protected, rust can appear on the undercarriage, especially in areas with harsh winters and road salt. Inspect the body carefully.
Driving Experience
The MINI Roadster offers a distinctive driving experience that blends the MINI's signature go-kart handling with the open-air enjoyment of a convertible. Here's a breakdown:
Pros:
- Agile Handling: The Roadster retains the MINI's sharp and responsive handling, making it a joy to drive on twisty roads.
- Open-Top Thrills: The electrically operated soft top provides a quick and easy way to enjoy the open air.
- Unique Styling: The Roadster's distinctive design sets it apart from other convertibles.
- Fuel Efficiency (Non-S Models): The base Cooper model offers decent fuel economy for a sporty roadster.
- Relatively Affordable: Compared to other premium roadsters, the MINI Roadster is generally more accessible.
Cons:
- Limited Cargo Space: As a two-seater, the Roadster offers very limited cargo space.
- Ride Quality: The ride can be firm, especially on models with sport suspension.
- Rear Visibility (Top Up): Rear visibility with the top up is restricted.
- Potential Reliability Issues: As detailed above, certain engine and component issues can be costly to repair.
- Wind Noise (Top Down): There can be significant wind noise at higher speeds with the top down, though a wind deflector helps.
Buying Advice
If you're considering buying a MINI Roadster, here's some advice to help you make an informed decision:
Years to Look For:
- 2013-2015 (Cooper S with N18 Engine): The later model years with the N18 engine offer improved reliability compared to the earlier N14. The Cooper S provides a significant performance boost over the base Cooper.
- Consider the Base Cooper (with caution): If you prioritize fuel economy and don't need the extra power, the base Cooper can be a decent choice, but still be prepared for potential maintenance issues.
Years to Potentially Avoid (or Inspect Carefully):
- 2012 (Cooper S with N14 Engine): These models are more prone to timing chain and HPFP issues. Thorough inspection and a documented maintenance history are essential. Consider a pre-purchase inspection by a qualified MINI mechanic.
Key Things to Check:
- Service History: A complete and documented service history is crucial. Look for evidence of regular oil changes, timing chain maintenance (if applicable), and other preventative maintenance.
- Timing Chain Noise: Listen carefully for any rattling noise from the engine on startup, especially on Cooper S models prior to late 2012.
- Soft Top Operation: Ensure the soft top operates smoothly and completely. Check for any tears or damage to the fabric.
- HPFP Condition: If buying a Cooper S, be aware of the potential for HPFP failure. Check for long cranking times or misfires.
- Rust: Inspect the undercarriage for any signs of rust, especially if the car has been driven in areas with road salt.
- Diagnostic Scan: Have a pre-purchase inspection performed by a qualified MINI mechanic, including a diagnostic scan to check for any stored error codes.
- Test Drive: Take the car for a thorough test drive, paying attention to the engine performance, transmission smoothness, suspension noise, and brake feel.
- Negotiate Based on Condition: Be prepared to negotiate the price based on the car's condition and any known issues. Factor in the cost of potential repairs.
By following this guide, you can increase your chances of finding a well-maintained MINI Roadster that will provide you with years of open-top enjoyment.
```